The United States and the
European Union should not
sign free trade deals with
the UAE until it ends its
mistreatment of foreign
One of the world’s largest
construction booms is
feeding off of workers in
Dubai, but they’re treated
as less than human. It’s no
surprise that some workers
have started rioting in
protest. What’s surprising
is that the government of
the UAE is doing nothing to
solve the problem.
Middle East and North Africa director at
Human Rights Watch (HRW)
View Full Text
Business is advisable with 'commendable' states, that is, towards countries in which the minimum standards of the state of law are respected. If ignored it would be like the Aspidistra, a plant which requires no attention till it breaks its pot, and when done, it needs to be put in a fresh
compost. ........ Testimony
"Corruption and the use of private security forces are two issues with direct impact on
businesses". ... Because human rights are not a
luxury for good times. Human rights are important for business
at all times, but particularly so now when public confidence
is at its lowest. In the long term, human rights are
fundamental for stable, open societies which businesses need
for their operations. Conversely, an environment in which
human rights are regularly and seriously abused is a risk
factor for companies.
imagine doing business in a society where your staff are at
risk of being arrested, detained or exiled for no apparent
reason? It is not rare, there have been numerous examples of
late of business people being detained. Will expatriate staff
be willing to stay? Can you afford to lose the investment in
recruiting, training and developing individual local staff?"....
"Companies should develop codes of conduct which are consistent with international standards on human rights. They should also ensure that they are implemented by all partners and
sub-contractors. .......And the performance should be monitored independently and reported publicly". Pierre Sane.
"The structures that protect human rights protect your business as well."
Human rights organizations are giving increased attention to the subject of business and human rights. The last few years business and human rights has become one of the more important new topics on Amnesty’s long-term agenda.
"What human rights can do for
Amnesty International’s 1997 brochure for business people
("Your business deserves a strategy", AI Index ASA 01/03/97)
Human rights are about respect for the people in your business and the society within which you operate.
Human rights ensure the protection of law and accountability of governments to businesses and individuals alike.
Human rights can protect you and your employees.
Human rights can contribute to the stability a country needs for its economy to grow.
Human rights are about being the kind of company and the kind of country that others want to do business
The structures that protect human rights protect your business as well.
Business needs integrity in national legal and fiscal systems so that:
you have recourse to law and are not subjected to arbitrary decisions or summary justice;
your reputation is not damaged by association with corrupt or criminal practices; you have a secure investment climate;
your intellectual property rights are protected;
you have the economic stability you need to plan for growth.
Business needs transparent government so that:
your success does not depend on "connections" with the right officials;
you are less vulnerable to abuses of power and arbitrary decisions;
you are able to obtain the information you need on business and economic issues; risk of civil unrest is diminished."
As Sir Geoffrey Chandler has said, there is no room for moral neutrality. Corporations which think they can remain silent will be doomed;
"they will be perceived as not just profiting in a repressive regime but as profiting from a repressive regime, and that will do irreparable damage to their
(Sir Geoffrey Chandler is the former Shell senior executive who headed the UK National Economic Development Office and who is now Chair of the Amnesty International British Section business group)
Mr. John Kamm, remarked on the occasion of accepting the
Best Global Practices award:
"Promoting respect for human rights and rule of law is good for business, and
business people – with the resources at their disposal, their negotiating skills and most of all their relationships – are uniquely qualified to do so."
John Kamm is a U.S. based businessman whose company received the 1996 "Best Global Practices Award" from the United States Department of Commerce for its promotion of human rights in China)
Companies are exhibit little concern to human rights abuses for fear that mentioning them might endanger the growth and expansion of their business. It's not a right sign, at least they should take human rights issues seriously.
The sovereignty is limited with respect to human rights. International supervision is valid and states are accountable to international authorities for domestic acts affecting human rights.
Fundamental human rights are designed to protect the inherent dignity of the human person, no matter what his or her culture or background: no person in any society should be tortured, or enslaved, or arbitrarily killed, or imprisoned without a fair trial, or deprived of fair access to food or education. These rights are set forth in international instruments which have been adopted by countries from all regions of the world.
"All peoples have the right of
self-determination. By virtue of that right they freely determine their
political status and freely pursue their economic, social and cultural
All peoples may, for their own ends, freely dispose of their natural
wealth and resources without prejudice to any obligations arising out of
international economic co-operation, based upon the principle of mutual
benefit, and international law. In no case may a people be deprived of its
own means of subsistence".